Understanding the Dangers of Gentle Parenting

Understanding Gentle Parenting: The Importance of Strategic Disengagement

Gentle parenting, first popularized by Sarah Ockwell-Smith in 2015, emphasizes emotional connection between parents and children while minimizing punishments for unwanted behaviors. This approach closely mirrors authoritative parenting, which balances warmth with firm boundaries. However, in its more mainstream form, gentle parenting faces criticism, with some arguing that it allows children to misbehave without consequences.

While social media influencers often offer advice on managing tantrums, much of it lacks scientific backing and can conflict with proven methods for handling oppositional and explosive behaviors in children. One key concept promoted by gentle parenting is "co-regulation" — where parents stay emotionally regulated to help calm their dysregulated children. This idea is supported by research, which shows that when parents remain calm, they help de-escalate tense situations.

However, not all gentle parenting advice aligns with best practices. Influencers often suggest “leaning in” — engaging with a dysregulated child to soothe them, even when the anger is directed at the parent. But this can backfire, prolonging the tantrum and preventing the child from developing crucial emotional regulation skills.

The Science-Backed Alternative: Strategic Disengagement

Evidence-based treatments for oppositional behavior, like Parent Management Training and Parent-Child Interaction Therapy, suggest a different approach: strategic disengagement. This means when a child becomes too dysregulated, the parent should stop engaging, avoid further interactions, and allow the child time to calm down.

Before disengaging, parents can calmly state something like, “I can’t talk to you when you’re yelling at me” and walk away. After the child has calmed down, the parent can re-engage in a warm, supportive way. Over time, this helps children learn to self-soothe and develop emotional regulation.

Disengagement: A Thoughtful Process

Disengagement is not about abandoning the child. Instead, it’s an active process of maintaining a calm, neutral demeanor and being ready to step in if safety becomes a concern. This strategy also works best when paired with reasonable consequences, like limiting screen time if tantrums are prolonged.

Teaching Emotional Regulation

Disengagement is a powerful tool for teaching emotional regulation. Children are more likely to learn self-control once the emotional storm has passed. Active learning doesn’t happen during a tantrum, but afterward, parents can discuss better ways to handle anger in the future.

Conclusion

Gentle parenting encourages warmth and emotional connection, which are key for raising emotionally secure children. But when it comes to tantrums, the science suggests it’s time to “lean out” rather than “lean in.” Strategic disengagement helps children learn how to manage their emotions, ultimately fostering better long-term emotional regulation.

Remember: YOU ARE NOT ALONE. If you need help and/or assistance, please contact fill out a “Request an Appointment” contact card today.